Main Attraction
What do students know about the House of Commons? Collect students ideas on the board - students should be made aware of the four main functions of the House - to pass laws, vote on tax to keep the government going, to scrutinise the work of government, to debate the major issues of the day.
In this clip, Alan B'Stard is arguing in favour of arming the police, at some point in the various stages of a fictional Bill. Delve a little deeper into the clip - what does it imply about the nature of debate in the Commons? Does it correspond with students' exposure to similar debates on TV? Why is debate important - consider the motion being discussed in the clip? How have the filmmakers used the setting to add to comedic value and what stereotypes or cliché's have they employed?
Explain that once Bills have been prepared they go through 5 main stages in the House of Commons (before moving the House of Lords).
- First Reading - Bill is introduced to the house; no debate
- Second Reading - Bill's purpose explained by Minister in charge, MPs questions are answered, time for debate followed by a vote for Bill to pass to next stage
- Committee Stage - Standing Committee (small committee of MPs) from each party, examines details of the Bill, amendments can be suggested and voted on
- Report Stage - If amendments have been added Bill is reprinted for members of the House. Further changes can still be suggested
- Third Reading - House considers the whole Bill (it cannot be changed at this point), debate, the Bill is either accepted or rejected.
Divide the class into three groups - the government, the opposition, the minority party - and ask them to prepare their ideas for a debate on arming the police (or another topic of your choice). At least one side of the House will need to be FOR and AGAINST - with students generating their own arguments. Encourage students to experiment with their language - thinking about the most persuasive or powerful way of delivering their points. Higher ability students should be encouraged to use their own knowledge of party political beliefs and the current political climate to inform their arguments.
Debates in the House of Commons are subject to time limits - it might be wise to set one here! With teacher (or a student) acting as Speaker of the House, debate the issue, using the same conventions as the Commons as far as possible (if you are feeling very energetic you might pull together a set of rules for students to abide by...). Once the debate is finished, ask students to vote - counting the Ayes and the Nos. Students need to be made aware that they do not always have to vote in line with their party!