After the critical and commercial success of The Lodger (1926), a follow-up
reuniting director Alfred Hitchcock and star Ivor Novello was an attractive
proposition, and a convenient vehicle suggested itself in the stage play Down
Hill, written by Novello with Constance Collier, under the combined alias David L'Estrange.
Despite a swift and happy resolution, Downhill is one of the darkest of
Hitchcock's early films. It is also probably his most persistently misogynist
work, with a succession of predatory and manipulative female characters who
combine to torment Novello's hapless young hero: the tuck shop girl who falsely
accuses Roddy of fathering her child; the selfish and mercenary actress who
marries him for his inheritance, then abandons him when she has finished
spending it; the vampiric 'Madame' who exploits his penury by hiring him out to
dance with her lonely, ageing clients.
At least some of the blame for this parade of monstrous women, however,
should be laid at Novello's door, and it's not hard to imagine that the play
reflects the experiences of a homosexual matinee idol oppressed by unwanted
female attention. Intriguingly, in the absence of a female focus, the camera's
fetishistic gaze falls on Novello's suffering. One early scene is particularly
revealingly: Roddy, fresh from his heroic achievements on the rugby pitch, is
involuntarily seen shirtless by his best friend's sister. Roddy's reaction -
grabbing a towel to conceal his naked chest - speaks as much of the actor's
sexually ambiguous public persona as it does of Roddy's own character.
While the direction is occasionally clumsy - the pace is uneven,
while a seemingly endless shot of a descending escalator is a clumsy symbol for
Roddy's downward trajectory - and Hitchcock was characteristically
disparaging about the film in later interviews, Downhill is a deceptively rich
and often elegant work. The Marseilles boarding house in which Roddy hits
rockbottom is lit like a Vermeer painting, and the earlier sequence in which
sunlight exposes the sordid inhabitants of a dancehall is impressive, if
unpleasant. Most striking is the scene in which the delirious Roddy, on a boat
bound for home, sees visions of his father and his past tormentors mocking him.
Inspired by his memory of stage lighting, Hitchcock had the sequence tinted a
sickly green to express both nausea and mental torment. Many years later, he
would employ a similar trick in Vertigo (1956).
Mark Duguid
|