In retrospect, it seems surprising that, after a decade of landmark political
television films, the director/producer partnership of Ken Loach and Tony
Garnett should choose the year Margaret Thatcher came to power to release a
children's adventure film. Garnett later wondered whether the film's real
motivation was a desire to achieve a cinema release after years of struggle,
taking advantage of the National Film Finance Corporation's funding
opportunities for children's films.
Loach's adaptation of Leon Garfield's 1968 novel changed the title character
to a Frenchman, played by Jean Franval - in a bid for French co-production
funding - and moved the story from Surrey to North and East Yorkshire, for their
unspoiled landscapes. Some of the cast came from South Yorkshire, because Loach
found the dialect simultaneously contemporary and historical: he re-used some
actors from his earlier 'The Price of Coal' (Play for Today, BBC, 1977) and drew
child leads Stephen Hirst and Louise Cooper from Barnsley schools (Cooper from
the former school of David Bradley from Kes, 1969).
The film was handicapped by financial problems. Shot in just six weeks in
summer 1978, it had a still more rushed post-production schedule, and Loach long
wanted to re-cut a film he considered "one that got away". He eventually
presented a shorter director's cut on the 2010 DVD release.
Despite its problems, Black Jack is a charming, underrated film. It shares
the concern of other Loach films for young people failed by their
elders and abandoned by society, and while the historical attitudes
to mental illness that it presents jar with those in 'In Two Minds' (The Wednesday Play, BBC, 1967)
and Family Life (1971), Belle's recovery after leaving bourgeois family
constraints echoes those productions' perspectives.
It's also an accomplished historical film, which sought to avoid other films'
anachronistic clichés through Loach's characteristic techniques, Martin
Johnson's design, and unconventional music - Bob Pegg's score and in-scene
performers such as Packie Byrne - which prioritises the people's popular music.
Chris Menges' photography, meanwhile, favoured the textures of old photographs
and paintings: exteriors were shot on grainier Super 16mm, with interiors - some
painterly, some almost under-exposed - on 35mm with low natural light and
candlelight.
Loach planned a follow-up children's series, Garfield's Apprentices, for
Southern TV, but couldn't attract the necessary international co-producers.
Garnett later criticised his own contribution to a film he "should never really
have done". This would be Loach and Garnett's final collaboration.
Dave Rolinson
|