Family Life marks Ken Loach's only cinematic collaboration with David Mercer,
who also wrote Morgan - A Suitable Case for Treatment (1966) for Karel Reisz and
Providence (1977) for Alain Resnais. Mercer took a fairly jaundiced view of the
family, which he regarded as a breeding-ground for oppression, frustration and
breakdown. In this, his views coincided with those of the Scots psychiatrist RD
Laing, whose ideas were highly influential in the 1960s. Laing suggested that
what society called 'mental dysfunction' or 'madness' was often the sole
rational response to intolerable social pressures - inflicted, as often as not,
by the family structure.
The story - adapted from Mercer's Wednesday Play 'In Two Minds' (BBC, tx.
1/3/1967; also directed by Loach) and shot in sober, quasi-documentary style -
could be summed up by Philip Larkin's notorious opening of his 1971 poem 'This
Be The Verse': "They f— you up, your mum and dad / They may not mean to, but
they do." Janice, the 19-year-old daughter of a lower-middle-class family, is
ceaselessly berated and browbeaten by her parents while being assured that
everything they do or say is "only for your own good". When she gets pregnant by
her boyfriend - of whom, inevitably, her parents disapprove - they push her into
having an abortion, then respond to her depression by taking her to a
psychiatrist.
The first consultant she sees, Dr Donaldson, is open-minded and liberal, a
follower of Laing and a believer in gentle group therapy. But when he's ousted
by the hospital board - in a scene that finds Loach's satirical scalpel at its
sharpest - Janice is transferred to a harsh regime of drugs and
electro-convulsive therapy. In the film's final scene she's been reduced to a
near-vegetable - passive, silent and unresponsive, exhibited to a smirking
audience of medical students.
As Janice, Sandy Ratcliff is limited by the script to do little beyond
reacting. Her parents, though, aren't shown as monsters; in their own way
they're as much to be pitied as Janice, no less trapped by the conventions and
assumptions of society. Her mother presents a figure of purse-lipped bourgeois
rectitude, misguidedly sincere in pursuing what she sees as Janice's best
interests; while her father, still conscious that his wife is a rung or two
above him on the social scale, squirms uncomfortably when Donaldson quizzes him
about their (evidently minimal) sex life. "She's a good woman," he mutters
unhappily, "I can't complain."
Philip Kemp
|