A proto-Ealing comedy, Cheer Boys Cheer is excluded from the official canon
merely by virtue of its date. The similarities with the classic postwar Ealing
titles are many: in its story of a large purveyor of poor beer versus a small
traditional brewery, it pits the small concern against the corporate; the
individual against the hierarchy; the paternalistic against the authoritarian.
Its chief difference to its better-known stable-mates is that there is no
transgression on the part of the protagonist/s putting them in opposition to the
authorities or the State such as there is in Man with the White Suit (d.
Alexander Mackendrick, 1951), Passport to Pimlico (d. Henry Cornelius, 1949) and
others. Perhaps because of this, Cheer Boys Cheer feels less substantial,
without the sustained tension or evenness of pace of the later films.
Nevertheless, with beer a subject dear to the hearts of all true Britons, our
sympathies are engaged.
Film historian Charles Barr has compared the film to Ealing itself: small
scale and cosy, run by a close-knit family that speaks its own language and only
shows its steely core when the chips are down. It has also been seen as an
allegory for the behaviour of the Nazis in the run up to the war. References to
Ironside's territorial ambitions, the language of annexation, the use of
grandiose fascist art deco design - to say nothing of the shot of Ironside
reading Mein Kampf - are quite explicit.
This seemingly light comedy conceals a harder message (most of the Ealing
comedies have one) represented by an unnecessary (at least to the plot)
character: the accountant, Saunders, played by Alexander Knox, whose searing
intelligence jars with the rest of the film. Saunders has two scenes with lines,
one without. In the first, he delivers a cold dose of reality by letting John
Ironside know that he is undeceived by his claims that the benefits of
advertising outweigh its costs. The second comes after Ironside's hired thugs
have instigated riot and brawling in the Greenleaf pubs (another Nazi tactic).
Faced with old man Greenleaf's evident defeatism, he exclaims, quite
passionately, "We've got to fight!". Considering that this script was being
worked on when Neville Chamberlain's more famous piece of paper was being held
aloft, and that war was declared a couple of weeks after the film's release, it
is not fanciful to read this as a rallying cry.
Bryony Dixon
|