Before they carved out comedy niches in successful sitcoms, John Le Mesurier
and Leonard Rossiter co-starred as a pair of doctors with opposing ideas on
medicine in this sophisticated satire, shown as part of the anthology drama
series Theatre 625.
Using Harley Granville-Barker's popular translation of Jules Romains' play,
the BBC made a version for schools in 1961 before this interpretation in 1966.
The role of Doctor Knock was originally popularised in the 1920s by actor Louis
Jouvet, who featured in two French film adaptations of the story as well
numerous stage versions. Though rarely adapted for the screen in recent decades,
the play remains an astute observation of the corrosive relationship between
medicine and commerce.
When country doctor Parpalaid leases his practice to the mysterious Doctor
Knock, he believes he has made a good deal from the quiet business of attending
to a small town. Knock, however plans to hugely expand the practice, using
'modern techniques' and sheer charisma to convince the residents that they
require an abundance of expensive care. Knock is a charlatan but a consummate
performer, and his genius is to inspire fear and create doubt in patients by
suggesting that minor complaints have serious causes. Rossiter's performance is
brilliantly understated, with every raised eyebrow becoming an inducement to
hypochondria. A contemporary review described him as using "a voice as bland and
soothing as glycerine and honey."
Herbert Wise, a veteran of television plays who would go on to direct
I, Claudius (BBC, 1976), uses gentle pans to suggest the slow pace of village life
and tight close ups that emphasise the alarm and discomfort of prospective
patients, as well as Knock's menace and calculation . Knock's oppressive
personality is especially evident in a claustrophobic scene in Parpalaid's
old-fashioned car, which acts as a metaphor for his traditional style of
medicine. Prolific designer Eileen Diss creates a suitably clinical feel in the
doctor's surgery and Knock's employment of medical illustrations is reflected in
the striking title sequence and in the end credits.
By exploiting his patients' hunger for the latest modern methods, Doctor
Knock is able to send almost an entire town to bed and Rossiter's
near-deranged performance in the penultimate scene illuminates the original play's
alternative title, 'The Triumph of Medicine'.
Lisa Kerrigan
|