For all its right-on, anti-sexist rhetoric, the alternative comedy scene was
slow to promote women comics. By the time Jennifer Saunders and Dawn French
joined the line-up at the Comic Strip club, their male co-stars Rik Mayall, Ade
Edmondson and Alexei Sayle were on their way to cult status. Similarly, the two
women had to make do with small parts in others' shows before finally winning a
series of their own, with Girls on Top (ITV, 1985-86) and, subsequently, French
and Saunders.
The series displayed the wilful amateurishness of much alternative comedy,
but shunned both the violence and scatology of Mayall and Edmondson and the
strident politics of Sayle or Ben Elton. The duo's humour was distinctively
female, but without the aggressive feminism favoured by some female comics of
the time. Men came in for some criticism, notably in the recurring 'two fat men' sketches, in which a pair of obese chauvinist grotesques leer at women and brag implausibly about their sexual conquests. Most of the jokes, however, were at the expense of themselves or each other, with sketches frequently falling apart and the partners routinely breaking out of character to bicker and criticise.
Early series took the form of a low-rent variety show, a set-up tailored to
the performers' studied clumsiness, and featured support from the similarly
gauche Raw Sex, a cod-cabaret keyboard/bongos act comprising Rowland Rivron and
Simon Brint. As audiences and budgets grew, however, the structure loosened, and
the pair increasingly favoured elaborate spoofs of pop acts - notably Madonna
and Bananarama - and movie blockbusters. The latter became an enormously popular
feature, to the extent that, however hilarious were their shambolic takes on the
likes of Titanic, Silence of the Lambs and Aliens, they risked eclipsing the
duo's other strengths.
Success may have been a while coming, but when they made it, they really made
it. The pair became something like a Morecambe and Wise of the alternative
comedy generation, winning a mainstream acceptance well beyond that offered to
their peers, excepting Elton and, latterly, Hugh Laurie. As they increasingly concentrated on other projects - Saunders with Absolutely Fabulous (BBC,
1992-2003), French with Murder Most Horrid (BBC, 1991-99) and The Vicar of Dibley (BBC, 1994-) - the gaps between their collaborations grew wider, with the
result that each new special or series was greeted as a television event.
Mark Duguid
|