The Legion Hall Bombing made detailed use of court transcripts to document a
trial of suspected terrorists in Northern Ireland. However, this factual basis
did not prevent the BBC from making cuts to the play, to such an extent that
writer Caryl Churchill and director Roland Joffé removed their credits in
protest.
A voice-over introduction established that the trial depicted, with no jury
and an acceptance of confessions obtained during intense interrogation, was
typical of terrorist trials following the 1972 Diplock Commission. Parts of this
introduction had been cut by BBC executives, who claimed to have removed
Churchill's editorialising personal opinion to leave a stronger, purely factual,
account. The executives also removed a voice-over conclusion, arguing that it
had been intended to lead into a discussion programme which had not subsequently
been made.
Although these changes prevented the play from heightening flaws in the trial
or in the post-Diplock judicial system, these ideas remained implicit in the
matter-of-fact depiction of prosecutions which were gained in spite of witness
statements, questionable police procedure and a lack of evidence other than
alleged verbal confessions. Therefore, the play's refusal to embellish upon its
transcripts with dramatic or stylistic flourishes worked in its favour, despite
a mixed response from newspaper critics, some of whom were bored by its
unwillingness to name protagonists or signpost dramatic tension. Recording
entirely on video in the studio, Roland Joffé respected the innate power of the
documented evidence and subtly built atmosphere through visual claustrophobia
and measured performances, including that of Jim Norton as a Detective Sergeant,
who prefigures Norton's obstructive RUC officer in Hidden Agenda (1990), Ken
Loach's film on Britain's alleged shoot-to-kill policy in Northern Ireland.
Like Loach's film and many other television plays and films, The Legion Hall
Bombing fell victim to a prevailing nervousness over representations of
terrorism and the 'Troubles' in Northern Ireland. In a review in The Listener,
David Wheeler compared The Legion Hall Bombing with his own research into
transcripts of the Widgery inquiry into Bloody Sunday for a BBC project which
was not ultimately made. With this in mind, and the increasing censorship around
BBC drama on other controversial issues - including the recent bans for
Brimstone and Treacle and Scum - The Legion Hall Bombing seemed fortunate to
survive. However, this climate ensured that the play was edited and transmitted
in a much later timeslot than was usual for Play for Today.
Dave Rolinson
|