Based on a popular 1946 novel, Trottie True can be related to the Victorian
music-hall world of Champagne Charlie (d. Alberto Cavalcanti, 1944) and Gaiety
George (d. George King, 1946), set against the background of the Gaiety 'musical
comedy' shows.
From the opening credits (over a red heart emblem) the central question is
evident: who will win the heart of Trottie? The candidates are obsessed
balloonist Sid Skinner; serious-minded aristocrat Lord Digby Landon; 'bounder'
Maurice Breckenham; backer of Gaiety Shows Arthur Briggs and fellow artiste Joe
Jugg, but morose Digby and dull balloonist Sid are the main contenders. Whereas
Trottie is a spirited gal, vivacious and lively, these men are a rather dull
bunch, lacking in any genuine gaiety or charm, so Jean Kent is able to shine
with her central star performance; not surprisingly, this was her favourite film
role.
The early vitality of the Bedford music-hall scene is not maintained, and a
major omission is the lack of a fully staged Gaiety number, especially as in
1948 there were still survivors around familiar with the original stagings. But
Rank were wary of funding lavish musicals following the 'disaster' of London
Town (d. Wesley Ruggles, 1946) and Jean Kent even had a struggle to keep her
songs in the film. The music score, by Benjamin Frankel, is full of old world
charm with a delightful opening 'trot' theme and waltzes such as the wistful
'Dreaming', composed in 1911 by English 'waltz king' Archibald Joyce, so
evocative of the Edwardian era.
There is much to enjoy in Trottie True, but these are mainly surface
pleasures. Both art direction and colour are first class, with much eye candy in
colour and form, art direction, and detail in costumes and millinery. Harry
Waxman's cinematography nicely differentiates the emotional temperatures of the
True family home, with its warm, dark colours, and the Wellwater stately pile,
in cold, light blues. Visual treats include an early close-up of a bird in a
gilded cage (bride as trophy?), Gaiety Girls travelling to a picnic in their
white dresses and finery, Bouncie's dressing room bedecked with flowers, and a
lavish servant's ball. British 1940s Technicolor films offer an abundance of
visual pleasures, especially when lovingly restored by the National Film
Archive. Trottie True is not among the best known, but comes beautifully
packaged, gift wrapped with all the trimmings.
Roger Philip Mellor
|