There is comparatively little history of civil disobedience and organised
dissent in Britain, which may explain why the protracted struggle for women's
suffrage proved so divisive and traumatic.
Shoulder to Shoulder dramatises this fight and was devised by actress Georgia
Brown (who also plays Annie Kenney), script editor Midge Mackenzie and producer
Verity Lambert. Each 75-minute episode focuses on one particular aspect of the
movement or one of its members. While organised roughly chronologically, the
episodes can also be viewed as stand-alone plays, reflecting the personalities
of their respective authors. Ken Taylor's three episodes ('The Pankhursts', tx.
3/4/1974; 'Christabel Pankhurst', tx. 24/04/1974; 'Sylvia Pankhurst', tx.
08/05/1974) deal specifically with the role of the Pankhurst family, and the
internal divisions that would eventually split them. 'Annie Kenney' (tx.
10/04/1974), by Alan Plater, is full of the author's trademark wry humour as it
follows the progress of Kenney from apolitical mill girl to militant
suffragette.
The tone darkens considerably in subsequent episodes and the series doesn't
shrink from depicting the terrorist activities undertaken by some of its more
militant members, or the horrors of the prison force-feeding to which they were
subjected. This is the focus of 'Outrage!' (tx. 1/5/1974) by Hugh Whitemore. It
is the most overtly didactic episode, as evidenced by the extended 12-minute
sequence in which Sylvia Pankhurst and a working woman debate the value of the
suffragettes' idealism in the 'real' world. This episode also uses songs as
ironic counterpoint, as when Gilbert and Sullivan's 'When a Felon's not Engaged
in his Employment' is heard over a montage of suffragette arrests. The series'
title comes from the lyrics to 'March of the Women', the suffragette anthem by
Edythe Smith (portrayed on screen by Maureen Pryor).
The generally excellent performances include Siân Phillips' stunning
portrayal of Emmeline Pankhurst and Fulton MacKay's passionate Keir Hardie.
Patricia Quinn's Christabel is somewhat two-dimensional, however, depicting this
complex character as little more than a ruthlessly ambitious tactician. The
series also sidelines the contribution of Adela Pankhurst, a controversial
figure who was finally sent to Australia and became extremely right-wing. Sylvia
is treated the most sympathetically of all the Pankhurst women for her
self-sacrifice and unwavering socialist idealism and humanism.
The series ends in 1918, when women of property over 30 were given the vote.
It would take another 10 years before women were given the same voting rights as
men.
Sergio Angelini
|